CIA’s secret on-line network untangled with a Google search– N.


According to reports, the US government is still reeling from a catastrophic, years-long intelligence failure that compromised its internet-based covert communications system and left CIA informants vulnerable to exposure and execution worldwide.

In 2013, following the compromise, CIA experts worked feverishly to reconfigure their secret websites and try to move their informants to safety, but intelligence sources say that damage this severe probably can’t be wholly undone.

Yahoo published a report last week about the previously unreported intelligence disaster.

According to Yahoo, which relied on 11 former intelligence and national security officials for the report, the problem started in Iran and “spiderwebbed” out to countries that were friendly to Iran.

It wasn’t just one point of failure: it was a string of them. One of the worst intelligence failures of the past decade was in 2009, when the Obama administration discovered a secret Iranian underground enrichment facility. The Iranians, furious about the breach, went on a mole hunt, Yahoo reports, looking to dig out foreign spies.

Unfortunately for the US and its agents, it didn’t take long to find the moles. That’s due in large part to what one former official called an “elementary system” of internet-based communications – one that was never meant to stand up to sophisticated counterintelligence efforts such as those of China or Iran, let alone one that should have been entrusted with the extremely sensitive communications between the CIA and its sources.

That system had initially been used in war zones in the Middle East, and entropy kept it in use by far more people, for far longer, than originally intended. Part of the problem is that it was easy to use, tempting intelligence agencies to overlook its shortcomings. Yahoo quotes a former official:

It was never meant to be used long term for people to talk to sources. The issue was that it was working well for too long, with too many people. But it was an elementary system.

Another former official:

Everyone was using it far beyond its intention.

Two of Yahoo’s sources from the intelligence community said that the Iranians had cultivated a double agent who led them to the CIA’s secret communication system, which it was using in areas such as China and Iran, where in-person meetings can be dangerous. The CIA eventually learned from Israeli intelligence that Iran had likely identified some of its agents.

Finding out about Iran’s discovery of its secret communications system didn’t put an end to the intelligence breakdown, given that the Iranians used a simple method to take the single thread of the initial website and use it to unravel the far wider CIA network.

Namely, they Googled it.

A former intelligence official says that once the Iranians were shown the website where CIA handlers communicated with their sources, they began to search for other websites with similar digital signifiers or components. By using simple Boolean search operators – like “AND,” “OR,” as well as more sophisticated ones – the Iranians eventually came up with advanced search terms that would lead them to other secret CIA websites.